Email: Password: Why register?
Bob Campbell, Master of Wine Bob Campbell is one of only 264 Masters of Wine in the world. An international wine judge, Bob judges wine professionally in ten countries and contributes regularly to publications around the world. His specialty is New Zealand wine which he reviews from an international perspective.
Home    Blog    Search: Advanced

Archive for the ‘Blended reds’ Category

A winery to watch

Friday, February 26th, 2010
Silverdale

Stillwater's first vineyard

Visited a brand new winery in the brand new area of Stillwater 30 minutes north of Auckland on the east coast. Paul Syms was sales and marketing director of a large English plastic company until he headed south to pursue his passion for wine. Syms built a house at Stillwater before realising that the neighbouring land offered a perfect vineyard site. Being a man of action he sold his house, bought the land next door, built another house, planted a seven-acre vineyard and built a winery – the last two with a little help from the owner of Providence Vineyard, Jim Vuletic.

Vines were planted in 2005 with the first harvest in 2008 (currently still in barrel). The vineyard is planted equally in Cabernet Franc, Malbec and Merlot. I visited the winery shortly before the arrival of bottling equipment (the first wines will be bottled in a couple of months).

A tasting of barrel samples revealed three impressive varietal wines – ripe flavours, good ripe tannins and nice acidity. Also tasted a test-blend of all three, which I preferred to any of the component wines, good though they are. This is a very serious wine in the making.

Syms plans to charge aound $60-70 a bottle – a fair price if my assessment is anything go by. There are no plans to run a cellar door although visitors will be welcomed if they make an appointment.

Paul Syms and wife_1 Web

Paul and Cathy Syms

Esk! Esk!! Esk!!!

Saturday, August 29th, 2009
New look for Esk Valley

New look for Esk Valley

 

Villa Maria/Esk Valley/Vidal owner, Sir George, and Esk Valley winemaker, Gordon Russell, dropped around to show off the new Esk Valley label design and share some of the new release wines. The label is a great improvment on its rather old-fashioned replacement (Reserve label shown above – regular label is similar without the numbers and without the word “Winemakers” which replaces “Reserve”).

Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc 2009 was pleasingly intense although just a tad too sweaty to earn a top score from me. I particularly liked Esk Valley Verdelho ($22.99), a wine I’ve been fairly lukewarm about in the past. Quite complex, dry and with a pleasing mineral character. It was significantly better than a Spanish Verdelho opened alongside it (Valdeorras Godello 2008 Gaba do Xil – weighty but too phenolic and drying). A dry-ish Marlborough Riesling 2009 ($22.99) also impressed. Nice purity, great acidity (how do you descibe acidity that is the opposite of hard? Somehow “sweet” doesn’t quite work. The acid was quite strong but pure and taut – it made me shiver slightly and salivate gently – I liked it very much). A weighty and cleverly balanced Pinot Gris 2008 ($22.99) followed. A touch of barrel fermentation added extra interest to a rich, velvet-textured wine that Gordon describes as his best yet. I’ve always liked the Esk Chardonnay and the 2008 regular label ($22.99) didn’t disappoint although it was out-gunned by the deliciously complex Esk Valley Winemaker 2008 Chardonnay.

On to the red wines starting with a Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec 2007 ($22.99) that punched well above its weight thanks to a cracker of a vintage. Very Bordeaux-like wine with dusty tannins and an attractive sappy complexity. Syrah 2007 ($22.99) was a wine that Gordon accurately describes as a “Shiraz for Pinot Noir drinkers” – a peppery, supple wine with silky tannins. There was certainly nothing Pinot Noir-like about Esk Valley Winemakers Syrah Gimblett Gravels 2007  which was as bold as its $60 price tag. This is a powerful red in a peppery Rhone-like style with masses of fruit supported by subtle, classy oak.

Esk Valley is in good shape under the enthusiastic stewardship of Gordon Russell.

george-gordon-sml

Sir George (left) and Gordon Russell

Blake Family Bordeaux blend beats the big boys

Thursday, October 30th, 2008
and the winner is ...

and the winner is ...

When a group of Gimblett Gravels winemakers organised a competitive tasting between their wines and the best from Bordeaux no one expected a Kiwi wine to come out on top. The best they hoped for was to at least have one or two wines in the hunt. Staging a comparitive tasting with the best wines in existence is a good ploy. If you (predictably) come second you still score points because your wines are so much cheaper and (hopefully) the gap wasn’t that great.
Here’s what happened. The organisers selected 24 Bordeaux blends from the Gimblett Gravels region – all from the 2005 vintage. They invited Australian wine guru, James Halliday, to pick the best six in a blind tasting. Retail value for the six bottles was $290. Six wines, including three First Growth labels, were purchased from the highly rated 2005 vintage. Cost $7,750.
The wines were served in a blind tasting to a guest list that included Halliday, Elin McCoy from New York (author of “The Emperor of Wine” – an excellent book about Robert Parker jnr), winemakers, wine enthusiasts and a “sponge” (this collective noun was suggested by a local winemaker) of wine writers. The scores of a handful of invited guests, including Parker and McCoy were used to get an “official” result.
Here is the list of the top wines, in order:

1. Blake Family Vineyards “Redd Gravels” Gimblett Gravels

2. Chateau Lafite-Rothschild Pauillac, Bordeaux, France

3. Sacred Hill “Helmsman” Gimblett Gravels

4. Mills Reef “Elspeth” Cabernet Sauvignon Gimblett Gravels

5. Chateau Mouton-Rothschild Pauillac, Bordeaux, France

6. Trinity Hill “The Gimblett” Gimblett Gravels

Here is a picture of James Halliday shortly before a tasting he called “both audacious and courageous”. I include the picture because I particularly like it.

Wine guru James Halliday in full flight

I spoke to James after the event. He said “This was no put up job. It’s hard to argue with the results which cannot be swept under the carpet”.

Here are my comments on the wine: “Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc blend that beat three First Growth Bordeaux and a bunch of other distinguished wines from the same vintage. This really is a very classy red – wonderfully dense, long and linear flavours contained by very fine tannins. An aristocratic wine without any hint of coarseness. Quite remarkable. Very complex although it’s difficult to describe the array of berry, floral, spice and savoury flavours.” Score: 97 points